| Summary: | dvdstyler produces coasters (movies stop after a few seconds) | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Product: | Fedora | Reporter: | Nils Philippsen <nils> |
| Component: | dvdstyler | Assignee: | Stewart Adam <s.adam> |
| Status: | RESOLVED FIXED | ||
| Severity: | major | ||
| Priority: | P5 | ||
| Version: | 10 | ||
| Hardware: | All | ||
| OS: | GNU/Linux | ||
| namespace: | |||
|
Description
Nils Philippsen
2009-03-08 07:31:53 CET
What player are you using when the DVDs do not play properly? Also, are you sure that you've selected the correct video format? DVDStyler defaults to PAL, but if you live in North America you need to set the DVD to be in NTSC (sorry if you've checked all of this already, but I'm suspicious about the settings since the DVD plays fine with VLC). (In reply to comment #1) > What player are you using when the DVDs do not play properly? Also, are you > sure that you've selected the correct video format? DVDStyler defaults to PAL, > but if you live in North America you need to set the DVD to be in NTSC (sorry > if you've checked all of this already, but I'm suspicious about the settings > since the DVD plays fine with VLC). I used a DVD player hooked up to my TV set (Cyberhome CH-452) _and_ VLC to check, i.e. with VLC it also stops when played as a DVD (only slightly earlier). Playing the individual .VOB files is what works (which is very strange). I'm in Europe and the PAL/NTSC setting is set correctly to PAL. Mind, I see some frames, then the movie stops. (In reply to comment #2) > I used a DVD player hooked up to my TV set (Cyberhome CH-452) _and_ VLC to > check, i.e. with VLC it also stops when played as a DVD (only slightly > earlier). Playing the individual .VOB files is what works (which is very > strange). I'm in Europe and the PAL/NTSC setting is set correctly to PAL. Mind, > I see some frames, then the movie stops. Okay, that makes more sense - does this problem only occur with this specific file or on all DVDs you try and produce? (By the way, I've built 1.7.2 locally & will submit a build as soon as the maintenance on the RPM Fusion builsystem has completed). (In reply to comment #3) > (In reply to comment #2) > > I used a DVD player hooked up to my TV set (Cyberhome CH-452) _and_ VLC to > > check, i.e. with VLC it also stops when played as a DVD (only slightly > > earlier). Playing the individual .VOB files is what works (which is very > > strange). I'm in Europe and the PAL/NTSC setting is set correctly to PAL. Mind, > > I see some frames, then the movie stops. > Okay, that makes more sense - does this problem only occur with this specific > file or on all DVDs you try and produce? If my memory serves me correctly, I haven't produced a working DVD with dvdstyler for a while. Granted that may not be very helpful, as I haven't gotten around to trying it for a while as well ;-). But definitely no working one with version 1.7.x. > (By the way, I've built 1.7.2 locally & will submit a build as soon as the > maintenance on the RPM Fusion builsystem has completed). Did you build against a new ffmpeg vfersion or have you patched dvdstyler to work with the old one? In the latter case, please share the patch, then I can maybe give you early feedback whether 1.7.2 remedies the issue. (In reply to comment #4) > If my memory serves me correctly, I haven't produced a working DVD with > dvdstyler for a while. Granted that may not be very helpful, as I haven't > gotten around to trying it for a while as well ;-). But definitely no working > one with version 1.7.x. I can confirm this part, dvdstyer 1.7.x didn't seem to interact well with our relatively new checkouts of ffmpeg > Did you build against a new ffmpeg vfersion or have you patched dvdstyler to > work with the old one? In the latter case, please share the patch, then I can > maybe give you early feedback whether 1.7.2 remedies the issue. ffmpeg was updated in CVS, so I built some RPMs locally and build against those... ffmpeg: http://cvs.rpmfusion.org/viewvc/rpms/ffmpeg/F-10/?root=free DVDStyler: http://cvs.rpmfusion.org/viewvc/rpms/dvdstyler/F-10/?root=free The new RPMs are in the repositories now - can you still reproduce the issue? Closing due to inactivity. Feel free to reopen if you can still reproduce the issues. |